A few months ago while I was browsing at ULTA, I noticed that there were many shades added to the Stila Smudge Stick Eyeliner range. Of course, I pulled a bar-code arm again...
Anyway, these are creamy pencil housed in a plastic retractable tube. Pigmentation is rich and they glide easily on the arm.
My favorites are probably those shimmery taupe/browns and the one in deep fuchsia.
How they look like in the display (took the pictures so that I can sort of remember the shades I have swatched)